What people keep running into with contractor disputes
Complaints tagged contractor disputes, each raised by more than one person. One-off posts are not included.
75 recurring problems · 1169 people · 27 forums we read
Raised more than once
Most people first.
- 4Why is water pooling on my new shingle roof?Water pools because contractors improperly install shingles on sections with too shallow of a pitch instead of using proper flat roofing materials. This causes standing water to accumulate on the bottom rows or between the ridge and chimney, leaving homeowners stuck with an expensive but defective roof.
- 3Is an exposed gas line safe during a remodel?Homeowners left with exposed gas lines during work are unsure whether it is safe to stay in the house or if a plumber needs to cap it first. Conflicting advice—such as warnings that gas lines cannot be clamped against a trunk, water heater, or metal exhaust—makes it hard to tell what actually needs to be fixed. That uncertainty leaves them wondering whether to call someone for help.
- 3Am I responsible for fixing plumbing work I didn't do?Homeowners are often held accountable for plumbing repairs like broken drain pipes or unverified water heater installations even when they did not break or disconnect them. Without an invoice or proof of who did the work, customers feel uncomfortable fixing unfamiliar property lines or pipes, leaving them stuck with unexpected repair responsibilities.
- 3Roof or gutter contractors missed rotting fascia boardHidden wood rot and sagging fascia are frequently discovered only after a new roof or gutter installation is complete. Because contractors often leave these structural issues unaddressed during the project, homeowners are left dealing with unexpected damage and costly disputes over who is responsible for the repairs.
- 3Contractor added hidden fees to final invoiceContractors often add unexpected charges like overhead and profit after the work is already finished. Because the job is done and insurance claims may already be maxed out, homeowners are left fighting to cover these surprise costs out of pocket.
- 3What to do when contractors blame each otherCompanies often avoid warranty repairs by pointing fingers at each other over the cause of the damage. One party will argue that integrating the materials was not in their contract, while the manufacturer or second contractor blames them for poor installation. This leaves you stuck with ruined work and wasted money while neither side takes responsibility.
- 2Will epoxy fill in rough spots and grinding marks?Epoxy does not completely fill in rough grinding spots or residual tool marks. These textures can stick out through the top of the finished coating, leaving an abrasive surface that feels like asphalt or coarse sandpaper. Because the floor constantly catches on microfiber washcloths, it becomes practically impossible to clean.
- 2Should I sign a contractor settlement agreement with a broad waiver?Broad release language and waivers covering known and unknown claims can cut off your rights if problems with poor or incomplete work show up later. Homeowners trying to get remaining corrective work finished while paying the full remaining balance also face clauses restricting where they can leave a review. That risk makes it hard to tell what terms are normal and what could leave you with no recourse after signing.
- 2Why is my new roof bulging?Prominent bulging can suddenly appear on a new roof just months after installation. Homeowners are left fearing that the only fix is a complete tear-off and redo of the affected area. Resolving the issue stalls when even the roofing company investigating the claim cannot identify what is causing it.
- 2Why is water still leaking after installing a perimeter drain?Contractors sometimes install the drain pipe improperly by placing it above the top of the footer instead of directly next to and slightly underneath it. Because of this, the exact same amount of water continues entering from the exact same location despite expensive repairs. This unresolved flooding causes immense overwhelm and anxiety attacks every time it rains until the workers finally come back to fix it.
- 2Installers left big gaps around new windowsInstallers often walk away from window jobs while leaving a massive cavity between the window and surrounding board or frame. When the installer refuses to take responsibility or install promised window sills, people are stuck with an incomplete job and openings straight to the outside.
- 2Is a gap around exterior pipes acceptable?Builders may claim a half-inch hole is acceptable, but this leaves a broken seal where daylight visibly passes right through from the outside. Instead of getting a properly fitted pipe, homeowners with no handy skills are left worrying about how to fix the gaping hole in their siding.
- 2Why do roof shingles have a line down them?Vertical lines appear on a roof when shingle joints are pushed up against each other instead of staggered and overlapping properly. Seeing what is underneath can signal poor installation that may lead to a leak soon. Homeowners who spot these aligned seams worry about future water damage and workmanship issues on their roof.
- 2Are exposed nails on a new roof acceptable?Spotting exposed nail heads on a newly installed roof immediately sparks worry about future leaks. Because it is hard to tell if missed nails are unavoidable or a valid complaint, people struggle to demand a resolution without fear of being fed a line of BS.
- 2Are gaps in new hardwood floors normal?Newly installed floorboards can immediately develop gaps large enough to fit a penny, even before experiencing seasonal humidity changes. This leaves people unsure if they should demand fixes or fight paying the full installation price. Because they do not know if individual boards can be replaced, many fear the entire floor must be completely redone.
Comes up alongside
Topics that keep appearing on the same problems — not topics with similar names.