What people keep running into with water heater
Complaints tagged water heater, each raised by more than one person. One-off posts are not included.
57 recurring problems · 690 people · 17 forums we read
Raised more than once
Most people first.
- 3Air coming out of hot water lines onlyTrapped air in hot water lines is often caused by a failing or recently replaced water heater that generates gas or allows air to enter the tank. Running the taps only offers a temporary fix because the underlying source of the air inside the system hasn't been resolved.
- 3Why are my cold taps running tepid after a water heater service?Servicing a tankless water heater can disrupt the balance, leaving cold taps running tepid for minutes and sometimes causing scalding hot water to push through the cold side. This unexpected crossover makes it difficult to get normal cold water and leaves residents caught in disputes with building management over who is responsible for the plumbing repair costs.
- 3Do water heater expansion tanks need extra support besides the pipes?Plumbing codes and inspectors often give conflicting advice on whether an expansion tank can be supported solely by its copper piping or if it requires a separate wall mount. This leaves DIYers uncertain about proper installation, risking unsupported weight stress on the water heater connections.
- 3Why does my water heater closet smell bad?Foul and musty odors in a water heater enclosure often stem from unmanaged maintenance like a neglected tank or tiny, hard-to-detect gas leaks around the pilot valve. Because the heater itself may run perfectly fine, finding the exact source becomes difficult and prevents homeowners from safely clearing out the persistent stench.
- 3Why does only the hot water smell like sulfur after moving in?Sulfur smells and dark stains appearing exclusively from the hot water after a house has been sitting empty can make appliances like clothes washers smell intensely when agitating. This issue often stems from an older water heater with an unknown maintenance history that has been left sitting unused.
- 3Why does my small water heater run out so fast?Compact 28-gallon heaters hold a limited supply of water that cannot keep up with long or back-to-back showers. Because tight physical spaces and a lack of gas service prevent installing a larger tank or tankless system, people are forced to cut their showers short or risk losing hot water entirely.
- 2Using a tankless water heater for radiant floor heatTankless water heaters used for radiant heat systems frequently suffer from black magnetic debris choking the inline filter and face skepticism from professionals who insist on boilers instead. This leaves homeowners struggling to select the right replacement setup, manage magnetite buildup, and handle simultaneous household hot water demands without running out.
- 2Dehumidifier still filling bucket with drain tube attachedConnecting a drip tube often does not automatically divert water away from the dehumidifier's internal bucket. People get stuck wondering whether the unit needs a setting or switch to use the continuous drain line, leaving the bucket filling up anyway.
- 2Is an indirect water heater worth the installation cost?Converting from a standard to an indirect water heater often requires over $4,000 in installation and boiler re-venting fees, on top of the tank itself costing double a conventional unit. This massive upfront expense makes it difficult to figure out if the potential gas savings and longer lifespan will ever actually pay off.
- 2Debris floating in water cistern keeps coming backWater cisterns in older flats can accumulate floating debris, bags, and towels that keep returning even after multiple cleanings. This persistent junk eventually plugs up attached plumbing fixtures, such as bidet showers connected to the flush tank inlet.
- 2Why does only the hot water smell like sulfur?Hot water heaters develop a sulfur or rotten egg smell when sulfate-reducing bacteria react with magnesium anode rods inside the tank. This makes the water unpleasant to use and often leads tenants and homeowners to mistakenly believe the well water itself needs cleaning.
- 2Why is my water heater getting hotter than the thermostat setting?Water heaters can overheat beyond their set temperature when a thermostat fails or sticks, causing dangerously hot water at the tap. Since renting a home limits your ability to service major appliances yourself, this requires contacting your landlord immediately to prevent scalding risks and potential equipment damage.
- 2How do I know what size tankless water heater I need?Tankless water heater sizing depends on your home's peak flow rate (GPM), which is calculated by adding up the flow rates of all appliances and showers you might use at the same time. Undersizing the unit will leave you with a shortage of hot water, while matching it correctly to your household demand ensures you do not fall short during peak usage.
- 2Green corrosion on new water heater PR valveGreen buildup can form on the top of the pressure relief valve within the first week of operation, even if there is no visible leak. This unexpected corrosion leaves owners dreading whether they can remedy the issue or if they must replace the entire water heater.
- 2Connecting a copper tee directly to a water heater inletIt is often unclear whether short brass nipples and unions are redundant when putting a copper tee right on top of the inlet. This uncertainty stalls installations for people relying on family help to avoid $3,000 plumbing fees, especially when they cannot afford to replace their existing galvanized pipes.
- 2Will a drip pan catch a bursting water heater?Standard drip pans cannot handle the massive volume of water released when a water heater suffers a sudden internal failure. Rusted heating element threads cause enormous leaks that bypass the pan entirely and completely flood the first floor. This leaves people trapped replacing the exact same unit every few years because they cannot afford an alternative system.
- 2Why does a plumbing connection still leak after putting it back together?Reassembling a joint to look aligned and firm does not always stop a drip, or a connection that worked for years can fail after nearby work shifts or stresses the fitting. Repeating the same reassembly without addressing hidden stress or joint failure leaves the leak ongoing.
Comes up alongside
Topics that keep appearing on the same problems — not topics with similar names.