Puppy blues and regret when training isn't working
Severe daily challenges like indoor pooping and excessive barking can trigger intense pet ownership regret, depression, and deep anxiety about daily life. Because standard training efforts often fail to stop the behavior, owners end up trapped in a cycle of stress, feeling forced to keep the puppy while dreading each day.
Core Friction Pattern
Analysis of 40 peer accounts across online developer and community forums reveals that “Puppy blues and regret when training isn't working” repeatedly surfaces due to edge-case mismatches between standard defaults and real-world environments. Standard troubleshooting frequently falls short, compelling practitioners to develop custom workarounds.
+62 alternative community-tested workarounds cataloged below.
What the numbers show
Counted from the threads quoted below. How we count
- People have been saying this in most months since September 2026.
- This comes up 24.8× more often in r/puppy101 than across the site as a whole.
What people tried
Every workaround mentioned in the threads below. We haven’t tested any of them — and nobody here is claiming they worked.
Found another way around this?
Share your steps and trade-offs so fellow engineers don't have to reinvent the wheel. No account required.
Puppy blues and regret when training isn't working
- 1Watching the puppy for poop behaviors and immediately taking him outside to ignore himDid this help you?
- 2Doing homework across the crate while the puppy napsDid this help you?
- 3Trying forced naps and experimenting with wake windowsDid this help you?
- 4Waiting extended periods outside for the puppy to defecate before leavingDid this help you?
- 5Taking the puppy outside every 45 minutes to an hourDid this help you?
- 6Throwing a celebration party with praise every time the puppy goes outsideDid this help you?
- 7Picking the puppy up in the middle of an indoor accident to relocate outsideDid this help you?
- 8Using crate rest or watching the puppy constantlyDid this help you?
- 9observing the dog's subtle cues and natural breed tendencies over timeDid this help you?
- 10changing activities to match what the dog actually enjoys, such as going for runs instead of visiting dog parksDid this help you?
- 11waiting through the adjustment period to see the dog's true personality emerge once they feel secureDid this help you?
- 12leaving the puppy in a gated front yard most of the dayDid this help you?
- 13putting a blanket over the crate to help the puppy settleDid this help you?
- 14moving the crate to a different area of the houseDid this help you?
- 15Engaging with a professional behavioristDid this help you?
- 16Practicing settle training and enforced crate napsDid this help you?
- 17Attempting distraction, high-value treats, and ignoring the behaviorDid this help you?
- 18Exploring potential pain medication and anti-anxiety medicationDid this help you?
- 19Blocking the dog in the living room at night instead of using a crateDid this help you?
- 20Buying separate futons to give the dogs their own spaceDid this help you?
- 21Purchasing toy alternatives to keep the dog busyDid this help you?
- 22Taking the dog on night-long walks and letting them out every two hours during the dayDid this help you?
- 23Introducing mental exhaustion games like snuffle mats and nose workDid this help you?
- 24Consulting a veterinarian about anti-anxiety medicationsDid this help you?
- 25Reaching out to the breeder for lineage insights or returning the dogDid this help you?
- 26Taking the puppy outside repeatedlyDid this help you?
- 27Changing feeding schedulesDid this help you?
- 28Bathing the puppy dailyDid this help you?
- 29Using enforced crate or pen naps every hour or twoDid this help you?
- 30Hand-feeding meals piece by piece to build engagement and training focusDid this help you?
- 31Using a long line for yard freedom while maintaining controlDid this help you?
- 32Providing various chew sticks like collagen, sweet potato, and bully sticks to redirect bitingDid this help you?
- 33Hanging a bell on the door handle for potty signalingDid this help you?
- 34Using snuffle toys and puzzle feeders with treats to calm the puppy downDid this help you?
- 35Attending class purely to learn training techniques oneself while not expecting the puppy to perform during the sessionDid this help you?
- 36Increasing the value of treats based on the level of distractionDid this help you?
- 37Asking the trainer to work at the edge of the room or outside the door to increase distance from other dogsDid this help you?
- 38Practicing focus and distance management outside of high-traffic areas or pet stores on one's ownDid this help you?
- 39Utilizing all food in training sessions with a strong focus on mental exercises and scent trainingDid this help you?
- 40Consistently building on foundations of impulse control and confidenceDid this help you?
- 41Establishing strict daily routines involving play, structured training, and designated crate/kennel downtimeDid this help you?
- 42Leaving the puppy with a frozen kong stuffed tight with food for enrichmentDid this help you?
- 43Switching feeding times by an hour or so to manage anticipationDid this help you?
- 44Taking the dog out for walks focusing on sniffing and stretching legsDid this help you?
- 45Adopting an adult dog (1-3 years old) from a shelter to skip the puppy phase entirelyDid this help you?
- 46Fostering a dog first before committing to adoptionDid this help you?
- 47Buying a spot cleaner (like a Bissell) to handle constant indoor pee accidentsDid this help you?
- 48Puppy-proofing the house by lifting all belongings and cables 40cm off the groundDid this help you?
- 49Looking up the 3-3-3 rule for dogs to understand adjustment periodsDid this help you?
- 50Enjoying the easy behavior while it lasts rather than worryingDid this help you?
- 51Taking the puppy back to the exact waiting spot repeatedly until they look for permission.Did this help you?
- 52Raising a knee slightly when the dog jumps to gently block them without giving rewarding attention.Did this help you?
- 53Putting strict obedience training on hold to focus on basics like name recognition and neutrality.Did this help you?
- 54Tethering the dog to a nearby piece of furniture with a chew toy to practice settling.Did this help you?
- 55Crating the puppy for a forced nap when they get too hyperactive or overstimulated.Did this help you?
- 56Singing or talking out loud when leaving the room to desensitize the dog to separation.Did this help you?
- 57Picking up the food bowl after 15 to 20 minutes if they refuse to eat, enforcing boundaries without coaxing.Did this help you?
- 58Enrolling in new classes like obedience, tricks, nose work, or agility to actively rebuild a bond outside of standard routines.Did this help you?
- 59Intentionally laughing to diffuse personal frustration and immediately pausing the activity so both owner and dog can calm down.Did this help you?
- 60Replacing standard neighborhood walks with swimming, hiking, or paddle boarding to provide better mental stimulation.Did this help you?
- 61Doubling daily exercise and mental activityDid this help you?
- 62Using specialized weather gear, anti-escape harnesses, and mesh furniture cratesDid this help you?
- 63White-knuckling through the phase until the dog matures and calms downDid this help you?
In their words
Unedited, grouped by where they were said, most upvoted first within each place, each linked to the thread it came from.
“I used to call my beagle stubborn when he'd plant himself halfway through a walk. Took me a while to see that he was working through a scent I'd marched right past.”source ↗
“I remember 3 years ago my wife and I had multiple points where we asked ourselves "what did we get ourselves into?" Lol.”source ↗
“thought my shepherd mix was just unfriendly at the dog park. she'd ignore every dog and sit near the gate staring at me. turns out she just thinks she's on duty and i'm the only thing worth watching.”source ↗
“We thought our dog would just randomly turn into an ahole until we realized all the jerk things he does are regular heeler traits.”source ↗
“I thought my she was outgoing, polite and gentle. Turns out she was just being like that because she desperately wanted approval. Now that she has unconditional love, she is disinterested and wary of strangers, obsessed with me, mischevous, and gets excited to the point of injuring both of us.”source ↗
“i thought he hated me. for like, a month or more he completely ignored me except when he wanted my seat on the couch in which case he get in my face and swat me until i (gently!) pushed him off.”source ↗
“I’m picking my 10 week old boy up on Thursday, and I’m looking forward to not sleeping for the next 6-8 weeks.”source ↗
“My puppy is approx 10 months old. She got spayed less than a week ago. A few HOURS after her surgery, she tried to get the zoomies and ended up back at the vet bc she’s so high energy that she didn’t realize that she was in pain and ended up throwing up bc of it.”source ↗
“I played seesaw with acceptance and regret for about 2 years. This dog was the slowest to mature that I've ever had. Peeing in the house was a problem no matter what I did. He chewed up everything for about 2 years as well.”source ↗
“My 16 month old just tore a hole in my 4 month old brand new sofa!!! But I love her, I am her world. She has no patience, cries till she gets what she wants, robs my seat, eats my food, pulls on the lead and pretends she isnt mine in the dog park most days”source ↗
“She is now eating the furniture. We dont even have a couch anymore because she ate the couch and loveseat so the family cannot even use the livingroom as theres no where to sit.”source ↗
“Judt came home and she ate the futon. Im at my wits end and dont know what else to do.”source ↗
“She is destroying out home and our lives.”source ↗
“What I wasn't prepared for was the sheer intensity of it all, the sensitivity, the level of management required and how much of my entire day would revolve around keeping this puppy regulated, entertained and comfortable combined with her selective nature and stubbornness of a pup who'll look at you as she tears up your carpet and will pick the carpet over high value treats and even a meal.”source ↗
“When we first got him, I went through really bad puppy blues and regretted getting him to the point of attempting to rehome him”source ↗
“He had a major issue with crying in his crate, jumping on everyone constantly and nipping/mouthing, zero impulse control, very reactive, and a nice touch of anxiety to top it all off.”source ↗
“I’ve had my golden retriever puppy since she was 8 weeks and she’s now 11 months old. The last few weeks we have been really struggling. She doesn’t listen to commands and has been refusing to eat her food that she would previously scarf down no problem.”source ↗
“Additionally, I just feel like we don’t have much of a bond. I know she loves me but I feel like she’s just made my life so much more difficult and hard to deal with over the last few months. I have no one to help me and I’m exhausted.”source ↗
“I feel horrible because he spend the majority of the day in his crate.”source ↗
“It’s really causing severe stress and anxiety not knowing if I can get where I need to be on time every day.”source ↗
“some mornings he will never poop and I get stressed because I feel like I cannot leave until he does.”source ↗
“Our puppy is now 14mo and she also stopped eating normally the past few months but now she’s back to her greedy hungry self.”source ↗
“Did the same when mine was almost a year old. That teenager phase tested us both be we endured and now it’s so much better at almost 2 years old.”source ↗
“Puppy seems to have very little impulse control, or maybe her curiosity is too big, she wants to make her own choices, or she just wants to be with us all the time.”source ↗
“She still jumps up at people and stands up to be nosy about what's on surfaces or try to get the tea towel off the counter.”source ↗
“Every walk seems to be a sniffy walk even though I try to get her to heel when we're on a footpath beside a road or crossing driveways for safety.”source ↗
“She still carries on barking and crying when we leave the room.”source ↗
“She has started to lay down in random spots but only settles for a minute or so before she's up to find something to do or get into that she shouldn't be.”source ↗
“The puppy era was particularly tough because I was just some lady and she had puppy stuff to get done at over 20 mph.”source ↗
“It hit every day around 2-3pm, and this guy went from playful puppy to sheer terror: peeing and pooping on the floor while staring me down, biting my ankles hard, tearing at my clothes, tearing at any cords he could find, barking nonstop, etc.”source ↗
“By contrast, it has been much more of a struggle training the pup - he still doesn't understand how to ask to go outside (we use a button), hasn't figured out his reflection is him, and is generally much further behind in learning commands than the older one was at this age.”source ↗
“I wonder at what point I might need to think about whether something is wrong, or is this a normal difference in their characters?”source ↗
“I’m losing patience. My puppy has zero interest in me unless it’s to bite me, genuinely hard.”source ↗
“No matter WHAT, he has shit in his crate at least once a day, every single day.”source ↗
“I haven’t slept more than 5 hours a night in the last month, not cause he won’t sleep in the crate but because I am so fucking behind everyday that I can’t even start my day until it’s over.”source ↗
“Am I still in the honeymoon phase or did we luck out and get an easy puppy?”source ↗
“She KNOWS what she should be doing, but she is just testing her boundaries and going through her teenage phase. There are days where I just cry on the kitchen floor, but I see glimpses of progress and know it’s going to get better with consistency and keeping myself positive around her.”source ↗
“Ours is seven months, and every time I think she has turned a corner, something else pops up! I keep hoping after a year. She is really sweet sometimes, and then she can just be very pushy trying to get her way.”source ↗
“now all of a sudden at 17 weeks, he forgot all his potty training, is chewing everything, and is just a terror.”source ↗
“my mom is in hospice so my nerves are shot.”source ↗
“We’ve struggled with our now 7.5 month Border Collie, with her frequently still jumping up to bite and lunging at us.”source ↗
“When in a frenzy, we are struggling to get her out of it; we’ve tried distraction, high value treats, ignoring.”source ↗
“This is what I thought 😆 the worst is yet to come. Coming to you live from the 13 week old trenches”source ↗
“I am struggling every single day with wondering if we made the right decision.”source ↗
“my partner has some frustrations but overall is very much in love with our puppy (I love him too, I am just not sure I like him very much and the feeling seems to be mutual) so rehoming is not and option (and would also break my heart).”source ↗
“I try my best to train him, but no matter what I try he almost refuses to poop outside, instead will poop inside the moment he steps inside.”source ↗
“Outside of this, I can no longer speak in my house, as he starts barking in a soul shattering screech if anyone speaks.”source ↗
“I am depressed from grieving, and am near giving up, it feels like I am breaking.”source ↗
“Enforced naps. Every hour or two the puppy goes in the crate (or pen) and has quiet time. It is a sanity saver.”source ↗
“the name game was a lifesaver for me too, my pup started locking eyes with me anytime she wasn't sure about something and it cut down on so many little freakouts”source ↗
“A "traffic handle" leash on his harness.”source ↗
“Granted ours is a golden and they are notoriously land sharks as puppies, but the chews really really helped her get out the urge.”source ↗
“A bell hanging on the door handle and ring it every time you take them out to potty. They eventually learn to ring them when they need to go potty”source ↗
“It’s almost impossible to get her to pay attention during class as she is heavily distracted by both the dogs and people.”source ↗
“It makes me feel like a failure at times. I’ve noticed the times I’ve cried about my puppy have been after these classes as it feels like she’s behind.”source ↗
“i just dread these classes due to her inability to focus.”source ↗
“I have a 9 mo french bulldog and am seeking advice on what I can do to held curb this on and off whining from 3pm-5pm.”source ↗
“I have a camera to keep an eye on him and he has consistently been whining on and off anywhere from 3pm until after I get home, despite the fact he gets potty and play only a couple hours prior.”source ↗
“I am really at a loss on what to do.”source ↗
“I have been having severe puppy blues with him the past couple of days due to whining so often despite our solid schedule”source ↗
“I have been crying the past couple nights and would love some advice from those who have gone through anything similar!”source ↗
“I have a mini dachshund, he’s 18 weeks old and every time I think he’s doing so much better a new problem arises 🤣🤣”source ↗
“We recently got a 6 month old from a. Shelter and I feel you. She is super smart and very good most of the time. But when she has an idea in her mind she will see it through if not prevented by us lmao.”source ↗
“Especially on walks it's very difficult with her sometimes when she doesn't wanna go somewhere she just plants down”source ↗
“My 6 mo old is the same. In fact, she seems to be more curious and more active than a few weeks ago.”source ↗
“My almost 4 month old mini dachshund doesn’t go a day without at least one accident in the house.”source ↗
“She seems to not like peeing outside sometimes.. we took her outside and ran around for 20 minutes and then right before we went inside we spent a minute saying “do your business” by her normal pee spot.”source ↗
“30 minutes later, she gets up off the couch (using her ramp) sniffs for one second and squats.”source ↗
“She also loves pooping in the house. We are better about this because she usually gives more cues, but sometimes she, in the middle of wrestling with our other dog, will just stop for a second and poop.”source ↗
“our puppy (6 months old doberman) will bark non stop when she’s in her kennel or in her x-pen if somebody is around her and not giving her attention.”source ↗
“i also thought she was doing better at going potty outside, but she has times where she’s still pooping and peeing in her kennel.”source ↗
“we don’t know what else to do, and I know the barking thing will go away with time, but we can’t even sit in our own home without this dog screaming at us.”source ↗
“i’ve already gotten attached to this dog, and I want her to get better at not barking at us, so I don’t want to give her away after having her for only 3 months… pls help…”source ↗
Where this came up
People with this problem also raised
Related community dilemmas clustered by discussion consensus
Why does my cat destroy everything including my hands?
Cats target everyday objects like water glasses, plastic, foil, and paperwork, and even attack human hands. This relentless destruction ruins personal belongings and leaves owners constantly cleaning up mess while wondering how to stop the behavior.
Puppy regression and behavior changes after an injury
Injury recovery and crate rest force a young puppy into sudden confinement, triggering severe behavioral regression like excessive barking, biting, and house-training setbacks. This constant chaos leaves owners unable to work or rest, as the puppy requires round-the-clock supervision and forgets all previous training.
How to potty train a puppy with a busy work schedule
Puppies need frequent outdoor trips to learn where to go, which clashes with long and irregular work shifts. Because accidents happen repeatedly inside the house while you are away, the puppy gets confused and cannot figure out that they are supposed to go outside.
How to calm down a hyperactive teenage dog
Adolescent dogs develop intense, relentless energy and attention-seeking habits that persist long after normal play sessions. This constant demand for stimulation causes training stalls and overwhelming frustration, leaving owners feeling completely burnt out and unable to cope.
How to tell normal puppy crate whining from real distress
Normal puppy protest involves brief complaining that eventually settles, while actual distress is marked by frantic pawing, shaking the crate, and escalation where the puppy cannot calm down. Mistaking real panic for simple whining prevents owners from stepping in to make the training exercise easier and creates severe tension between partners.
Why is my puppy constantly humping everything?
Puppies frequently hump toys, littermates, and people seemingly out of nowhere, leaving owners confused about whether this behavior is normal. When owners try to stop it with commands, the puppy often just pauses briefly and continues, making the habit difficult to break.