How do I know if a contractor quote is fair?
Homeowners often lack the baseline knowledge to evaluate whether high-stakes repair estimates—such as a $10,000 foundation fix—are reasonable. This leaves them feeling clueless and vulnerable to overpaying, especially when facing urgent structural fears and limited funds.
Core Friction Pattern
Analysis of 136 peer accounts across online developer and community forums reveals that “How do I know if a contractor quote is fair?” repeatedly surfaces due to edge-case mismatches between standard defaults and real-world environments. Standard troubleshooting frequently falls short, compelling practitioners to develop custom workarounds.
+222 alternative community-tested workarounds cataloged below.
What the numbers show
Counted from the threads quoted below. How we count
- The most recent one is from November 2026.
- This comes up 10.8× more often in r/HomeImprovement than across the site as a whole.
What people tried
Every workaround mentioned in the threads below. We haven’t tested any of them — and nobody here is claiming they worked.
Found another way around this?
Share your steps and trade-offs so fellow engineers don't have to reinvent the wheel. No account required.
How do I know if a contractor quote is fair?
- 1Getting multiple quotes from different contractors4 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 2getting multiple contractor quotes4 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 3getting multiple additional contractor quotes to compare pricing3 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 4Getting multiple quotes to compare costs3 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 5Getting multiple competing bids from different companies2 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 6getting multiple quotes2 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 7Asking online forums for community feedback2 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 8getting multiple competing contractor quotes2 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 9Getting multiple contractor estimates to compare2 people mentionedDid this help you?
- 10asking online forums or communities for price validationDid this help you?
- 11Consulting an independent structural engineer before getting repair bidsDid this help you?
- 12Shopping around for multiple competing quotesDid this help you?
- 13Asking contractors detailed questions about scope, drainage, and soil workDid this help you?
- 14Asking online forums for community input on price fairnessDid this help you?
- 15Checking if the contractor is licensedDid this help you?
- 16Asking online communities for advice and comparisonDid this help you?
- 17Manually comparing line items and warrantiesDid this help you?
- 18waiting on additional quotes from other companiesDid this help you?
- 19using chatgpt to build hvac knowledgeDid this help you?
- 20Seeking second opinions from independent plumbers or online communitiesDid this help you?
- 21waiting for additional estimates to compare rangesDid this help you?
- 22Go with a small shop because they are more likely to give a fair price to offset lower operating costs.Did this help you?
- 23comparing multiple contractor bids and specificationsDid this help you?
- 24researching equipment brands onlineDid this help you?
- 25researching different equipment choices and seeking advice onlineDid this help you?
- 26getting multiple contractor quotes before evaluating project costsDid this help you?
- 27researching average prices per square foot onlineDid this help you?
- 28Searching previous subreddit threads for price comparisonsDid this help you?
- 29Seeking a second opinion on whether components can be repaired instead of replacedDid this help you?
- 30Doing the work independentlyDid this help you?
- 31Hiring a handyman instead of a specialized rooferDid this help you?
- 32shopping around with small mom-and-pop shops instead of private equity owned companiesDid this help you?
- 33leaving old equipment abandoned instead of paying for removal and zoningDid this help you?
- 34paying out of pocket instead of filing an insurance claimDid this help you?
- 35doing parts of the labor or DIYing the repairDid this help you?
- 36Doing the installation and plumbing work yourself as a DIY projectDid this help you?
- 37comparing multiple contractor bids and asking online communities for a reality checkDid this help you?
- 38searching for specialized local tradespeople through vinyl supply distributorsDid this help you?
- 39Comparing project costs based on location and pipe typesDid this help you?
- 40asking for itemized cost breakdowns of materials versus laborDid this help you?
- 41checking material costs independently onlineDid this help you?
- 42getting a separate quote for labor only while purchasing materials yourselfDid this help you?
- 43Getting multiple quotes from different HVAC companiesDid this help you?
- 44Scheduling a quote through a home warrantyDid this help you?
- 45Comparing quotes against general industry pricing such as $75 to $100 per tread and riserDid this help you?
- 46Asking online forums for feedback on designs and quotesDid this help you?
- 47Comparing multiple contractor estimatesDid this help you?
- 48getting three quotes before evaluating project costsDid this help you?
- 49Asking online forums for price estimates and opinions on the quality of proposed repairsDid this help you?
- 50getting multiple minimum estimates and withholding the insurance breakdown until contractors provide their own numbersDid this help you?
- 51Asking online forums if the pricing is reasonableDid this help you?
- 52Comparing quotes based on equipment sizing, location, and potential obstaclesDid this help you?
- 53Comparing prices and components online or asking for community feedbackDid this help you?
- 54asking AI and a few other peopleDid this help you?
- 55consulting online forums to check for red flagsDid this help you?
- 56Reading every quote line by line and cross-referencing details like warranties and material specifications before signing.Did this help you?
- 57Asking each bidder for the exact scope (retrofit vs. full-frame tear-out) and getting the exact product series in writingDid this help you?
- 58Checking HOA rules for frame color, glass tint, and liabilityDid this help you?
- 59Vetting contractors by license number and workers' comp rather than online reviewsDid this help you?
- 60reaching out to multiple other engineers for alternative quotesDid this help you?
- 61keeping looking for other contractorsDid this help you?
- 62considering engineered concrete insteadDid this help you?
- 63comparing line-item scopes across different bidsDid this help you?
- 64following up with contractors to clarify missing materialsDid this help you?
- 65Searching on GoogleDid this help you?
- 66Creating a detailed side-by-side list matching the items one-by-one, observing exclusions.Did this help you?
- 67Taking the detailed quote, removing prices, and showing it to the cheaper contractor to ask what their quote includes and have them put prices in.Did this help you?
- 68Running the unit through the winter without making changesDid this help you?
- 69Seeking second opinions from other techniciansDid this help you?
- 70Only asking for specific fixes like installing a rack while skipping tubing replacementDid this help you?
- 71Contacting multiple contractors to compare bidsDid this help you?
- 72Seeking opinions and validation on online forumsDid this help you?
- 73calculating material costs independently and subtracting them from lump sum quotesDid this help you?
- 74seeking guidance and pricing reviews from online communitiesDid this help you?
- 75asking online communities for pricing feedbackDid this help you?
- 76Getting multiple quotes from different companiesDid this help you?
- 77Having a family member do part of the installation workDid this help you?
- 78Considering smaller separate multi-zone systems instead of one large unitDid this help you?
- 79Evaluating whether traditional ducted systems are a viable alternativeDid this help you?
- 80Comparing contractor bids against other quotes or online benchmarksDid this help you?
- 81Asking on forums like Reddit to see if prices are normalDid this help you?
- 82Getting multiple alternative quotes from different contractorsDid this help you?
- 83Comparing costs per square or against past home improvement projectsDid this help you?
- 84Asking online communities for price comparisons and second opinionsDid this help you?
- 85Getting 3+ quotes and comparing themDid this help you?
- 86Doing the project as a DIYer to save moneyDid this help you?
- 87Reading online reviews and checking local reputationDid this help you?
- 88Comparing multiple bids and asking roofers about specific lingoDid this help you?
- 89Looking out for obvious high-pressure tactics or massive upfront depositsDid this help you?
- 90researching materials and shingle specs onlineDid this help you?
- 91asking contractors to clarify discrepancies via emailDid this help you?
- 92consulting online communities for advice on what details to look forDid this help you?
- 93comparing quotes from multiple different local contractorsDid this help you?
- 94asking online communities or forums if specific estimate amounts are fairDid this help you?
- 95Evaluating material costs separately to see if they account for half the total priceDid this help you?
- 96Trying to take photos independentlyDid this help you?
- 97Asking online communities like Reddit for advice and second opinionsDid this help you?
- 98Getting quotes from alternative companiesDid this help you?
- 99Attempting to clean parts like flame sensors instead of replacing themDid this help you?
- 100Consulting AI agents for price estimationDid this help you?
- 101Checking industry pricing guides or asking online forumsDid this help you?
- 102considering doing the repair work themselvesDid this help you?
- 103asking online communities to evaluate project costsDid this help you?
- 104Doing the manual labor yourself over a weekendDid this help you?
- 105Getting multiple quotes or checking the scope of work before payingDid this help you?
- 106Requesting multiple quotes to compare pricesDid this help you?
- 107Asking online forums for feedback on contractor pricingDid this help you?
- 108Turning to online communities like Reddit to crowdsource opinions on quotesDid this help you?
- 109Doing the insulation project DIY by renting a machine and buying materialsDid this help you?
- 110Asking online forums for community feedback on quote fairnessDid this help you?
- 111Checking which specific chemical products or treatment materials the company plans to useDid this help you?
- 112Seeking feedback online from community forumsDid this help you?
- 113Paying for multiple separate inspection fees to get competing estimatesDid this help you?
- 114Comparing quotes with neighbors or online communities to gauge fair pricingDid this help you?
- 115getting more estimatesDid this help you?
- 116asking for the full scope in writingDid this help you?
- 117checking if permits are being pulledDid this help you?
- 118verifying decking replacement detailsDid this help you?
- 119Comparing multiple contractor bidsDid this help you?
- 120Selecting the middle-priced quoteDid this help you?
- 121Evaluating contractor organization and readinessDid this help you?
- 122DIY installationDid this help you?
- 123researching pricing onlineDid this help you?
- 124searching online to check typical pricingDid this help you?
- 125questioning the contractor's diagnosisDid this help you?
- 126Hiring a local handyman instead of a licensed plumber to save moneyDid this help you?
- 127Asking online forums for feedback on whether a pricing structure is standardDid this help you?
- 128getting multiple estimates from different contractorsDid this help you?
- 129shopping for equipment onlineDid this help you?
- 130asking for itemized breakdowns of time and materialsDid this help you?
- 131DIY sealingDid this help you?
- 132Getting additional quotations from other specialized remediation companiesDid this help you?
- 133Avoiding general pest control companies for specialized remediation workDid this help you?
- 134Having a local contractor come out for an in-person visit to assess the ground slopeDid this help you?
- 135Defining project requirements independently before requesting bidsDid this help you?
- 136Creating a post-bid evaluation checklistDid this help you?
- 137Relying on individual contractors to explain inclusions and exclusionsDid this help you?
- 138Breaking down material versus labor costs to evaluate fairnessDid this help you?
- 139Asking online communities if a quote is within the normal price rangeDid this help you?
- 140Considering mixing on-site vs ready-mix optionsDid this help you?
- 141Asking neighbors for recommendations and checking online reviewsDid this help you?
- 142removing the drain pan, emptied it to avoid more damage and cleaned itDid this help you?
- 143making other calls to other repair companiesDid this help you?
- 144considering cash discountsDid this help you?
- 145installing crack monitors online to watch unreinforced areasDid this help you?
- 146comparing equipment brands and distributor availabilityDid this help you?
- 147checking licensing and permitsDid this help you?
- 148evaluating whether the contractor is a small family-owned shop or a one-man show with lower overheadDid this help you?
- 149requesting estimates without additional partsDid this help you?
- 150waiting for separate pricing breakdownsDid this help you?
- 151Getting multiple competing bids from other tree service companiesDid this help you?
- 152Consulting online forums to compare pricing and project descriptionsDid this help you?
- 153Asking for advice and comparing line items on online forums like RedditDid this help you?
- 154Relying on personal referrals from coworkersDid this help you?
- 155Evaluating contractor thoroughness during inspectionsDid this help you?
- 156Reading online about whether contractor guarantees are usefulDid this help you?
- 157Considering license status and personal recommendations (friend of a friend)Did this help you?
- 158requesting multiple quotes from different contractorsDid this help you?
- 159comparing product upgrades like shingles and ice and water shield optionsDid this help you?
- 160asking online communities or forums for feedback on project scopes and costsDid this help you?
- 161Getting another quote to compare prices and scope of workDid this help you?
- 162Researching shingle product tiers and weather requirementsDid this help you?
- 163researching online and asking communities like Reddit for pricing feedbackDid this help you?
- 164Asking online forums to review photos of equipment and price quotesDid this help you?
- 165Telling contractors to kick rocks or refusing the recommended serviceDid this help you?
- 166Checking and verifying home measurements using floorplansDid this help you?
- 167Using AI tools like ChatGPT and Claude to calculate square footage and layoutsDid this help you?
- 168Moving on to source from other contractorsDid this help you?
- 169getting a few more quotes before decidingDid this help you?
- 170asking for real numbers and experiences from others onlineDid this help you?
- 171trying to break down costs by square footage and pitchDid this help you?
- 172Asking both contractors for an itemized breakdown of the required work, including removal, decking, insulation, and drainageDid this help you?
- 173Asking contractors to explain their scope of work in plain languageDid this help you?
- 174Getting a third written bid to identify which of the original estimates is an outlierDid this help you?
- 175Getting multiple contractor bids to compare pricesDid this help you?
- 176Asking online homeowner communities to evaluate pricingDid this help you?
- 177Doing manual installation labor like digging footers yourselfDid this help you?
- 178Hire local independent professionals instead of large private equity-backed companies.Did this help you?
- 179Avoid businesses that present tiered pricing options.Did this help you?
- 180Compare the specific materials included in each quote, such as new decking.Did this help you?
- 181Determine the exact size of the roof in squares to benchmark against local pricing standards.Did this help you?
- 182Getting multiple quotes from smaller, local independent contractors instead of national chainsDid this help you?
- 183Hiring a general handyman or house painter to seal gapsDid this help you?
- 184DIY fixes like stuffing steel wool into the holesDid this help you?
- 185Ignoring unsolicited assessments when there is no active problemDid this help you?
- 186Asking online forums for baseline estimates before soliciting official bidsDid this help you?
- 187Offering to do prep labor like digging trenches to lower the total billDid this help you?
- 188Learning how to DIY the project if contractor quotes come back too highDid this help you?
- 189Asking online forums for a gut check on the price.Did this help you?
- 190Breaking down the estimated material cost versus labor hours to see if the math makes sense.Did this help you?
- 191Asking online forums for advice on what questions to ask contractors during walk-throughs.Did this help you?
- 192Asking each contractor to put the exact same scope of work in writingDid this help you?
- 193Calculating the price per square to compare bids apples-to-applesDid this help you?
- 194Asking contractors to confirm their on-roof measurements in writing to find discrepanciesDid this help you?
- 195Posting the quote details and photos online to ask professionals if it is fair.Did this help you?
- 196Asking contractors to itemize demo, prep, and installation costs separately.Did this help you?
- 197Getting multiple estimates from different local contractors.Did this help you?
- 198Leaving the old flooring in place and installing directly over it to avoid demolition costs.Did this help you?
- 199Asking on online forums for local price benchmarksDid this help you?
- 200Getting labor-only quotes and buying materials online to lower costsDid this help you?
- 201Direct messaging local contractors on forums for referrals and estimatesDid this help you?
- 202Asking tradesmen on online forums for a second opinionDid this help you?
- 203Getting at least two additional quotes from different companiesDid this help you?
- 204Contacting the original builder to see if the damage falls under warrantyDid this help you?
- 205Requiring contractors to detail exact installation methods, material brands, and decking replacement assumptions in writing.Did this help you?
- 206Consulting home insurance agents to see if specific roof installation methods affect premiums or qualify for mitigation credits to offset cost differences.Did this help you?
- 207Comparing quotes against what other homeowners paidDid this help you?
- 208Checking component costs versus installation labor separatelyDid this help you?
- 209Adjusting or trueing up the existing door instead of replacing itDid this help you?
- 210asking online forums to evaluate quotesDid this help you?
- 211comparing against historical quotes from previous yearsDid this help you?
- 212checking if specialized electrical requirements justify the high costDid this help you?
- 213Working with an independent landscape designer first before getting quotes from contractors based on that designDid this help you?
- 214Getting a detailed itemized quote from one contractor and bringing the redacted version to another to establish a baselineDid this help you?
- 215Comparing quote line items and material specificationsDid this help you?
- 216Seeking community input on whether extreme price variances are normalDid this help you?
- 217Verifying overhead, insurance, and permit requirementsDid this help you?
- 218creating comparison tables to line up estimate detailsDid this help you?
- 219asking online communities for guidance on how to compare contractor proposalsDid this help you?
- 220Asking for specific details about completed roofs with similar features like chimneys or dormersDid this help you?
- 221Researching equipment pricing onlineDid this help you?
- 222Get three quotes before evaluating project costsDid this help you?
- 223Ask a forum for feedback on whether quotes sound reasonableDid this help you?
In their words
Unedited, grouped by where they were said, most upvoted first within each place, each linked to the thread it came from.
“Team of 3 dug up other plants and weeds that were not well kept, including some small mulberry seedlings, laid down a barrier and put the mulch where you see it. Stone edge pavers were already there. They planted the small plants where those dying shrubs, about chest height, used to be. About all I know.”source ↗
“How am I supposed to compare these companies at all?”source ↗
“This just seems all over the map.”source ↗
“Its this a F-off price or is this the typical price for just the engineering plans for a retaining wall?”source ↗
“Got a quote for 17.3k. My FIL was going to build us a patio for a wedding gift which was started and never finished. It seems like his work is kind of shoddy and I’m going to have to pay to demo his work.”source ↗
“Is $25,000 steep for a 20” tall, 74 liner foot retaining wall?”source ↗
“Yesterday, I was quoted over $1,000 for a 3’ x 11’ concrete trash pad. Is that within the normal price range?”source ↗
“I wasn’t concerned at first, but when I got this quote they mentioned he completely messed up drainage (I think he had drainage going towards the house) and when they tried to sit on his “wall” part of it fell off underneath them”source ↗
“We’ve been asking when they’re coming back to finish for 2 years now and keep getting pushed back.”source ↗
“I am putting in a 750sqft bluestone patio. I got quoted $50/sqft, is that a good price?”source ↗
“By the description of work it sounds high but them saying it’s 3 days of work makes it sound more reasonable.”source ↗
“Make sure you get 3-5 quotes before you make a decision.”source ↗
“This is the trades industry in a nutshell, it’s up to you to find a way to compare apples to apples.”source ↗
“I’ve received quotes with price differences of around $2K–$3K. So, I’d like to understand what would be an appropriate price for my requirements.”source ↗
“My poor friend got dropped because she put in a claim for some ice damage to her roof and gutters.”source ↗
“It cost me about $35,000 last year to have my house resided and painted with hardiplank. So 3500 seems definitely concerning low.”source ↗
“if a company is quoting 18.5k for standing seam + redecking and everyone else wants 32k+ for asphalt, you either found a gem or there's a catch.”source ↗
“So just looking for a gut-check.”source ↗
“Looking at gutters for my house, ranch house, no peaks and valleys. 50 feet straight shot on both sides. Garage is 28 feet straight shot bith side, and the barn is 40 feet, also straight shot. Quoted 2650 for house and barn or just 1980 for house. Black, seamless with the downspouts. Is that a fair deal?”source ↗
“I just got quoted 1750 for 50 feet, seamless w gutter guards, metro detroit”source ↗
“Just 50 feet total?! Were looking at roughly 240 feet total if we do the barn”source ↗
“Was basically quoted $450 each for driveway seal and walkway seal.”source ↗
“Are these decent prices in Connecticut?”source ↗
“$450 per seal seems a little steep unless they're doing crack repair and prep work too”source ↗
“Orkin came to my house for an inspection and wants to encapsulate the space. They're giving me an estimate of $15,000 to treat the mold, encapsulate, and install a dehumidifier.”source ↗
“how bad is this and is the estimate too high?”source ↗
“We were very surprised at the price, almost $70,000, and really just want to know if this is what something like this costs today.”source ↗
“I had three quotes: $14,200, $15,800, and $18,900. Obviously the $14,200 one looked best on paper. I almost signed.”source ↗
“Then I went line by line and noticed the cheap quote didn't include a warranty on labor - just materials.”source ↗
“You have to read every quote line by line and cross-reference, which took me most of a Saturday.”source ↗
“Anyone else caught a hidden gap like this before signing? Feels like this happens way more than people realize.”source ↗
“The qoute I got to fix it, is $3000?? Is that right??”source ↗
“I have no idea which contractor to choose out of these 2, because I’ve read that the guarantees are essentially useless.”source ↗
“Looking for input if this is a reasonable quote from a local roofing company.”source ↗
“I don’t have much experience with roofing so not sure what this type of job should cost.”source ↗
“I want to make sure I’m not being ripped off by my roofer. What’s the average cost to repair these including material? He quoted me $1,800”source ↗
“One issue I’m running into right now is a bid states a shingle that is a class 4 when I look it up but they stated in an email that they install class 3 impact rated .”source ↗
“and said all our flashing on the roof was "tin" and needed replacing and he'd do it for 4 grand.”source ↗
“Is he trying to pull a fast one here?”source ↗
“Google seems to think 4k is double what it should be. And I'm also worried that it won't actually fix the problem.”source ↗
“Could you please help with this initial quote that im very much interested in? Is this too low or reasonable? Any chance they are cutting corners?”source ↗
“We’re getting quotes for a full tear-off on a 1,900 square foot two story in Columbus, Ohio and the spread is wild. Low bid is $11,400 and the high one is $19,800 for what looks like the same architectural shingle.”source ↗
“CT - low was $12k but it was too difficult to communicate with the roofer / high end was $18k.”source ↗
“Would you replace or repair? I prefer to repair as I am just buying the building and have others issues to address first.”source ↗
“did share the report with some contractors and received repair quotes from $14,000 to $800.”source ↗
“Do manufacture certifications matter? Is a 15 year workmanship warranty needed or will anything show up in the first couple of years?”source ↗
“help me figure out which roofing estimate is the best!”source ↗
“I have thoughts on which seems best, but don't know what I don't know.”source ↗
“The quotes we've gotten use a lot of words I simply don't understand and they all just hand over a total and I'd rather understand what I'm buying first”source ↗
“Been quoted £2,600 for the work. Does this seem fair? It’s a reputable company and happy to pay good money for good work. I just have zero clue.”source ↗
“Any tips for understanding the details of an estimate? I found one company a few people in my neighborhood used and the new roof looks good with good reviews from the neighbors themselves, but what else do I look for when picking a company?”source ↗
“Make sure the estimate clearly covers decking, flashing, ventilation, warranty, cleanup, and extras.”source ↗
“Hello r/roofing! I'm a single first time homeowner navigating a roof replacement on my own and I don't have people I can ask for advice like this”source ↗
“Does Option B’s double underlayment on the lower-slope area, ridge ventilation, HVAC saddle/cricket, heat-welded TPO detailing and more explicit flashing scope justify roughly $2,300 more?”source ↗
“If this were your house and the goal was a durable roof for the long term without unnecessarily overbuilding it, which scope would you prefer and why?”source ↗
“Is this material better than a Landmark Pro, which I got quoted $8k for?”source ↗
“not better than landmark pro no. but duration is solid and this price is fair.”source ↗
“That price difference is crazy. I’d definitely be getting a few more quotes before deciding.”source ↗
“The price and referral for Roofer 2 is very attractive, but is it too good to be true. I'm also a senior and don't want issues with my roof. I can't climb up there to see if the job was done properly.”source ↗
“Dealing with roofing and cancer at the same time... I just don't know what to do. Hope for the best or go for as my DH calls it, the Cadillac option.”source ↗
“Is this reasonable? Another quote is about $6k more and the difference is the installation and additional layer of the underlayment. Will I be ok with just a mix of mechanical and foam installation with only one layer of the underlayment applied straight to the wood decking?”source ↗
“Before picking between those three, I'd close these gaps in writing”source ↗
“Quoted $5.6k to replace 3500 fasteners. Does that sound about right? Seems like a lot of screws.”source ↗
“My concern is the contractor(s) will adjust their scope of effort and/or materials to match the estimate.”source ↗
“Homeowner here, not a pro. I’m collecting quotes for a full replacement, and I’ve read enough horror stories to be paranoid.”source ↗
“What are the quieter red flags in a quote or a sales visit that would make you walk if you were the customer? I’d rather hear it from the trades than learn it from a leak.”source ↗
“>The first did a whole sales pitch on Duro-last roofing, quoted us $6,800 to replace both sections of flat roof with Duro-last. >The second quoted as $15,000 to replace both sections of roof with EPDM roofing, which everything I've read is supposed to be the 'cheap' option, comparatively. >I know nothing about roofing and my wife knows even less. Does the first company just doing a hack job for cheap? Is the second one just way overcharging us?”source ↗
“Wanting professional opinions on pricing for a roof replacement.”source ↗
“I've received quotes ranging from 9k to 32k from different roofing agencies, but the pictures and pricing guide in this post are from the most thorough inspection I've had so far.”source ↗
“Had a couple leaks this year that I've had to fix. Also attic mold and moisture issues (visible in the pics) which the roofing company attributes to bad airflow with the roof”source ↗
“i made the mistake once of handing over the paperwork right away and suddenly every quote matched exactly to the dollar. learned that lesson quick”source ↗
“Does this quote seem fair for replacing a concrete driveway in Southeast Michigan?”source ↗
“Is this a reasonable price, or is there anything else I should know about?”source ↗
“$60,000 for a retaining wall. Am I getting fleeced?”source ↗
“Trying to see if this is a good quote or not.”source ↗
“Just wanted to hear people's thoughts before pulling the trigger.”source ↗
“Hi everyone, I’m looking at redoing our small bathroom and I have two proposals in front of me that are VERY different price-wise and it’s left me wondering whether one is actually cheaper or whether they’re just pricing totally different scopes.”source ↗
“Basically I’ve had projects before where the quote looked fine at the start and then once work was underway there were suddenly a bunch of things that “weren’t included.’’”source ↗
“So I guess my question is how do you guys compare bathroom proposals when the project types are written so differently?”source ↗
“Is $1,950 for an installed ProVia door a fair price?”source ↗
“Compressor will sit on roof in direct sunlight and high heat AZ environment. That's really my biggest concern.”source ↗
“I notice one is a Heatpump vs Straight AC.. Not sure if that means much.. I literally never turn on my heat..”source ↗
“I sent one installer this information with several photos, and he quoted me $4500-5500 for just the labor - no materials, removal of toilet, sink, or baseboards or anything else.”source ↗
“He said the subfloor would have to be removed and replaced. I'm in the greater Boston metro area. Thoughts? I was very surprised.”source ↗
“We're busy af and cant get multiple people over here in a timely manner to compare quotes, so figured I'd just turn to this.”source ↗
“I’m trying to figure out how much I need to prepare to pay for it.”source ↗
“I only ask here before requesting plumbing quotes because last time I needed work done to the house I got a run around and prices that were 500% higher than what I knew labor and material plus profit markups should cost. I don’t want to get taken on this since I’m sure it will be very costly.”source ↗
“Am I that out of touch with contractor labor rates?”source ↗
“That’s a deal, about half of what I paid last year. I never knew how expensive doors were.”source ↗
“Does $13,630 seem like a fair price for two Goodman furnaces with this additional work?”source ↗
“Can someone confirm that this is outrageously overpriced or is this really the cost of business?”source ↗
“I’m new to home ownership and need guidance.”source ↗
“Getting multiple quotes seems like good advice, but I’m curious how homeowners actually compare them when the contractors aren’t necessarily pricing the same scope.”source ↗
“One proposal might clearly include demolition, disposal, restoration, permits, warranties, or follow-up work, while another may barely mention those items.”source ↗
“At that point it becomes difficult to know whether you’re comparing prices or completely different versions of the project.”source ↗
“A contractor quoted me $4800 to replace 10 sheets of t1-11 on a 2 story. What is your thought? It seems a bit high imo.”source ↗
“As a NJ homeowner, getting a licensed tradesman to even fart in your direction is a minimum of $750.”source ↗
“i got 3 quotes for similar work couple years ago and the range was wild, like $900 to $2100. i'd wait for the other quotes before stressing too much”source ↗
“When I researched prices per square foot, the highest I saw was $75, but that included materials. I know quotes aren't always figured on a square foot basis, but either way, this quote looked very high.”source ↗
“Not sure how to decipher who is honest and good quality, as prices vary wildly.”source ↗
“I'm wondering how I go about hiring someone to give it to me straight about whether or not we need new gutters/roof or if we can just handle repairing the gutters and waiting for an issue with the roof.”source ↗
“My concern is that if we bring out a roofer / gutter person for a quote, they'll tell us we need all new stuff even if we don't.”source ↗
“I'm a bit lost on how to navigate this!”source ↗
“I had a similar situation in my place, '72 build, never touched the fireplace for 3 years because I was convinced it'd burn the whole house down. Got three quotes and they all landed between 5k and 7k for the full liner and tile removal.”source ↗
“Paying for multiple inspections stings but 250 bucks to avoid a 6500 mistake isn't the worst math.”source ↗
“i just had 3/8 inch t1 11, basically just two sheets for $980. added membrane and primed. - just two corners of my garage. california though.”source ↗
“Given I paid 5k or so for a legacy steel installed or 8k for French door variant, yes.”source ↗
“All I can tell you is in 2018 I paid $3,600 for a 120k btu 97% efficiency, installed. I have no idea what HVAC has done since then, but maybe some more quotes would be worthwhile.”source ↗
“I was just quoted upwards of $1900 and that seems pretty steep but I don’t wanna make assumptions about skilled labor cost.”source ↗
“First quote I got was $5k.”source ↗
“Second quote, the guy detailed work to be done: supply and install 100amp panel and breakers, 75ft 2-2-2-4 SER feeder cable, relocating furnace blower and water heater and install line for EV router, $1400.”source ↗
“considering the neighborhood I live in it feels like he is trying to take advantage, rather than giving me an FU quote.”source ↗
“I've hired very few contractors in my day so I don't have much experience to lean back on and am hoping you all might offer me some guidance on if this pricing is even close to reasonable.”source ↗
“definitely looks like a bad quote to me.”source ↗
“I got an $84k quote from Costco for 18’ of bifolds so $3.8 seems ok…. FML.”source ↗
“We've had other jobs bid like a tankless water heater or a roof and they might come in a bit over what I was expecting like 10%-30% but 3800/square seems super high to me.”source ↗
“Called to get a quote on soffit and gutter replacement and was quoted 20k. This is for 28 vents and 250 feet of soffit. I’m blown away. I was thinking 10-12k. Is this an F you price or are things just this crazy? I’m afraid to call someone else for another quote, I’d rather get my ass on a ladder and save 20k.”source ↗
“Is this a fair quote? I am based out of round rock Texas and this is my first time looking for a landscaping project.”source ↗
“I was quoted $6,500 to have the liner installed (as well as breaking out old tiles and sealing bricks).”source ↗
“Is this excessive or what I should expect? I plan to have another company come out for a quote but each inspection is about $250-300.”source ↗
“Definitely get at least 2 more quotes to at least compare, maybe more.”source ↗
“Before accepting, I would want to establish whether the scope of work definition is sufficiently complete to give you confidence in the final cost.”source ↗
“what’s a fair price for this in NC? My quote includes 20MM plastic, dehumidifier, sealing HVAC, new door, electrical hookup, annual checks for 5 years, 5 year warranty on humidifier, 25 years on the plastic, and all the other necessary improvements for $13,000.”source ↗
“We just had a basic encapsulation done for 6500 up in the Carolina mountains.”source ↗
“Our encapsulation was around $20k a couple years ago. We're in NoVa, pretty HCOL.”source ↗
“We are asking for credits for the following. Wondering if anyone has any of these done before and how close were actual costs and quotes?”source ↗
“We're getting multiple quotes but our first was $1800 for 4 2.5 story downspouts and a front porch. This seems pretty high to me.”source ↗
“I was quoted $1400 for the entire job, including materials, labor, and the sheet metal brake rental. Also has a one year workmanship warranty. Is this too high?”source ↗
“I am being quoted $625 (originallu $735 but member discounts apply) labor and cost to replace a shut off ball valve in the crawl space of my house in CO. Is that considered a fair quote?”source ↗
“i ended up spending more time comparing estimates, warranties, and reviews than i did thinking about the actual roof.”source ↗
“the part that surprised me is how difficult it is to compare contractors when everyone seems to offer something slightly different. one quote looks cheaper until you read the details, then another looks better until you start looking at what's not included.”source ↗
“I spoke to someone from Home Depot today and he was at $3,800. Seems high..”source ↗
“Reason for not wanting to get more quotes: if this is just how much things cost now then why waste everyone’s time?”source ↗
“I just got a quote from a local company to get new gutters on my 20ish yr old, 1400 sq foot house in a major city in central NC.”source ↗
“Can I please get some feedback on this pricing? It seems very expensive to me”source ↗
“My concerns are that since this is a highly rated company, they can justify charging more than a mom and pop place and also once they start, they'll find wood rot and other things that will cause the price to balloon”source ↗
“My mother recently noticed a few cracks in the foundation for her home. Fearful the house would come down crumbling she got some people to take a look and they said it would be $10k in total to repair.”source ↗
“In all honesty we not have that kind of money so im hoping to find a better solution :(”source ↗
“After their free inspection, they confirmed that I am NOT infested with bats, but that the gaps they noted could allow for this and suggested I seal them to prevent a future infestation. They offered to do this for about $4,200, which seems wayyyy higher than I expected.”source ↗
“That's a big number to pay when I don't even have a problem! Thoughts? Suggestions? Is this worth it?”source ↗
“Yes, were the same people. And I see. will do Thank you so much for the advice! I am honestly clueless about this kind of stuff.”source ↗
“Wondering if you guys think 12,500 is reasonable for this amount of fencing in IL? That is the lowest of 3 bids I received on the project”source ↗
“I had gotten a quote from Orkin as well that was like $6k...and they just wanted to remove the squirrels and slap a patch over the hole. I called a smaller independent contractor... He replaced the facia board, and about a 12 foot section of gutter for $900.”source ↗
“Groundworks told me they could do 5 wall anchors across the wall for around 9k This includes materials, labor and SE inspection. They said they could possibly do a discount and get it down to 6,500”source ↗
“A local company told me the same but quoted me 10k, which was upsetting because I thought local would be more affordable.”source ↗
“I finally found another local company who said they could put steal beams up instead of wall anchors... without an SE and permits and charge me 3,900 for two beams”source ↗
“I was quoted 12k which includes all labor/permits etc. Does this seem high?”source ↗
“Does anyone know what the general price ranges for a replacement of a 400ft basic pine privacy fence with 2 doors would be around Knoxville Tennessee?”source ↗
“So far I’ve gotten several quotes that range a bit from $35-55 per ft. I typically hire the middle ground price, but wondered if that range seems far off currently.”source ↗
“Got a fence quote online without anyone visiting how accurate was yours?”source ↗
“Trying to figure if these no-visit quotes usually hold, or if the real bill jumps once they see the posts and the grade.”source ↗
“I had quotes of $11k to $15k for 287' long x 6' tall pvc fencing with 2 gates and we settled on a quote that was around $12k.”source ↗
“I have dug footers for my own fence which was much smaller than yours. Doing that properly is a major pain in the ass worth paying for.”source ↗
“I have received 3 quotes so far for james hardie fiber cement siding and they vary widely.”source ↗
“My question is, does anyone know what a fair price would be?”source ↗
“Anyway, just wanted to ask if this seems reasonable? I certainly don’t want to over pay, but I also understand I have zero frame of reference for what is plumbers charge so I don’t want to overpay either.”source ↗
“4 Bids on a full system replacement. Help me decide and not get distracted by the noise.”source ↗
“This will be my first full system replacement. I’m leaning towards Company D Carrier. Which one would you recommend?”source ↗
“Hi all — looking for a quick sanity check on this quote before moving forward.”source ↗
“I sure hope that’s the after picture. If not, these are some scammers you’re dealing with.”source ↗
“Is this reasonable? AprilAire 800 humidifier seem pretty popular but I wasn’t sure if the quote is fair”source ↗
“We currently have a pass through humidifier which averages humidity around 30(not great)”source ↗
“We need a new furnace and asked them for a quote and it’s almost $3K lower than everyone else we got quotes from. Is Goodman a red flag necessarily?”source ↗
“recently got quoted by two different HVAC technicians for replacing my outside and inside unit as well as various other things listed in the quotes.”source ↗
“One technician is charging $9300 for a 15 seer unit and the other technician is charging 12,500 for a 15.2 seer unit.”source ↗
“This is out of my wheelhouse and I really appreciate any help anybody can offer”source ↗
“I am mainly trying to understand whether the ~$54k total is reasonable for the full scope.”source ↗
“Is this quote reasonable?”source ↗
“Hey everyone. So I was quoted 33k for a 5 zone mini split system and a new electric water heater.”source ↗
“Hey folks, I was quoted $620 to pull and clean this blower wheel on my variable-speed Carrier heat pump. Does this need cleaning and is it a fair price? Tech said it wasn't super urgent but recommended it.”source ↗
“had the first guy come out and quote $1789 for replacing pipes to the roof from the furnace and it’s flu.”source ↗
“Had a second guy give me a quote today for only $650 and he’s well reviewed online with almost two decades experience.”source ↗
“is pricing that varied in HVAC? Was the first guy just weirdly expensive?”source ↗
“Our furnace went kaput last night so I have been running the gauntlet of companies in the area. I have had some companies coming in 3k lower than others with all the bells and whistles / coverage.”source ↗
“I'm looking for guidance one what I should go with and why, as well as if these quotes actually make sense.”source ↗
“Just trying to gauge if I'm getting actual, competitive pricing and if their proposals make sense.”source ↗
“I did get a proposal from an outfit here in town that seemed insanely pricey, but I'm just not familiar with the tech these days.”source ↗
“$19,000 installed for:”source ↗
“I’m trying to get more info on these choices...”source ↗
“I’m not looking for a super cheap entry-level system, but I also don’t want to pay primarily for a premium brand name or complex tech that may not provide much benefit in a relatively moderate climate.”source ↗
“Heat exchanger on our Goodman furnace is cracked and leaking, getting quotes to replace the gas furnace and ac unit.”source ↗
“I feel like this is insane am I out of touch with recent prices?”source ↗
“I am not too familiar with the current prices, but the quote seems to be on a higher end. What do you guys thinks?”source ↗
“I am trying to get multiple quotes to replace what are easily a 30 year old gas furnace and A/C unit in my 1300 square foot house.”source ↗
“So far, I have gotten 3 quotes and they all seem wildly different.”source ↗
“These numbers feel rather wide ranging for me and it's making it hard for me to make a decision.”source ↗
“I was quoted $5,800 for a new condenser and also includes a retrofit from R22 to R407C. Does this seam reasonable?”source ↗
“Seems a little steep to me but you did not include sizing or location or any obstacles that could raise the price.”source ↗
“We feel that this is a lot considering the whole unit & install cost the previous owner 3000$. Are we being scammed ?”source ↗
“This was my first estimate I got. I’m trying to find some other companies to come out. I’m posting to really see if this is to be expected”source ↗
“The quote for parts and labor is $1870 is this reasonable and necessary? Just a girl trying to figure out if this is actually necessary”source ↗
“Out of warranty as I’m the third owner. Showing no symptoms as of last season. Have not turned it on this season yet, I was getting it serviced in preparation for fall and winter when this was discovered.”source ↗
“I received a quote for $24,300 before a $750 Mass Save rebate to replace an existing heat pump system.”source ↗
“Does this seem like a reasonable price range for a cold-climate multi-zone Bryant system in Massachusetts, or should I get more quotes?”source ↗
“So just want to know if this is normally what is it. As when I ask some AI agents, they all said 24K is still high end price.”source ↗
“I have a *boiler for hot water baseboard heating and one of the pipes that goes to the pump is rusted.”source ↗
“They wan't $1800 which seems like a lot?”source ↗
“How much should I expect to pay in the northeast for hyper heat single zone 18k btu mini split installed. I am getting wild deltas between quotes?”source ↗
“We've been quoted $9,600 to replace the old boiler with a Navien NCB-H 130k combi boiler. The quote seemed reasonable to the other 12k+ bids we received. I was wondering if the quote seemed reasonable based on our current setup. Or is there another recommendation that we should pursue?”source ↗
“It’s for sure worth investigating, but I’m already horrified at how much that quote was.”source ↗
“Looking at getting LG Red 3 Ton Ducted Heat Pumps installed. I see indoor/outdoor pairs being sold retail online for around $6k. A pro just quoted me $11.5k. This is in addition to $7k of labor costs. I figure some markup is to be expected, but 100% seems excessive. Am I wrong?”source ↗
“I am wondering what you all think about this quote and if you know a reliable appliance repair company.”source ↗
“I made some other calls to other repair companies, most of them sound like a scam, or some broker tries to connect us with local techs rather than directly reaching out to the local techs.”source ↗
“I was just quoted $4,000 for labor to remove current flooring and replace with vinyl.”source ↗
“This is my first house and trying to get a good idea of costs for upgrades before comparing estimates.”source ↗
“What's a reasonable price per sq. ft to remove old laminate, dispose, and install engineered hardwood?”source ↗
“Local flooring company quoted $1500-1600 for labor only to install LVP on 13 steps. Is that a good price?”source ↗
“I’m about 30 minutes outside of Boston. I would be providing the flooring, as I have extra boxes on hand from the previous owner. How would you price if you were only needed for labor?”source ↗
“I'm trying to learn how installers break a labor quote into pieces when the customer supplies the material.”source ↗
“The quote from the contractor, however, had an additional 95 square feet of floor to be removed than is actually there, plus, the contractor's sales rep added 33% on top of his total measurement for waste, which I thought was far more than necessary.”source ↗
Where this came up
People with this problem also raised
Related community dilemmas clustered by discussion consensus
Is my home renovation quote reasonable?
Homeowners often receive a total job cost but have no idea about actual pricing. This makes it impossible to tell if the estimate is reasonable without seeking outside opinions.
Are commercial HVAC quotes and unit sizes reasonable?
Determining whether a contractor quote and equipment size are legitimate is difficult when faced with high costs like ten to twelve thousand dollars for a cassette or twenty-four thousand for a multi-head system. Without clear benchmarks for capacity and pricing, it is impossible to know if the proposal is fair or if the recommended unit is appropriate for the space.
How to know if my home renovation budget is realistic
Homeowners often lack the baseline construction data needed to determine if an initial cost projection is accurate. Without a reliable way to validate these estimates, people struggle to move forward with planning or avoid unexpected financial overruns.
Why are contractor and window replacement quotes so absurdly high?
Aggressive sales representatives heavily inflate price estimates, such as quoting $146,000 for a handful of doors and windows, under the assumption that homeowners do not know what the work should actually cost. This makes homeowners feel taken advantage of and leads them to actively discourage others from using those companies.
Should I switch contractors when they raise their prices?
Sticking with a reliable contractor who raises their rates by 10% is often safer and cheaper than risking an unknown replacement who might not show up or will charge high service call fees just to look at the job. Finding someone new is a gamble that usually ends up costing more in the long run.
How do you know if a contractor's work is actually bad?
Spotting bad construction or restoration work leaves homeowners struggling to figure out if visible flaws like uneven tiles, poor waterproofing, or missed deadlines are normal or require tearing things out and starting over. Without clear standards, people are left second-guessing what they see and stressing over whether to confront the contractor.