Should I ask the contractor to redo work or take a deduction?
Salespeople frequently sign the agreement but fail to relay specific aesthetic choices or installation upgrades to the crew doing the actual work. This forces you to either accept a financial deduction for the ignored details or risk the crew messing up the project even more if you demand a redo.
Core Friction Pattern
Analysis of 10 peer accounts across online developer and community forums reveals that “Should I ask the contractor to redo work or take a deduction?” repeatedly surfaces due to edge-case mismatches between standard defaults and real-world environments. Standard troubleshooting frequently falls short, compelling practitioners to develop custom workarounds.
+13 alternative community-tested workarounds cataloged below.
What the numbers show
Counted from the threads quoted below. How we count
- The most recent one is from November 2026.
- This comes up 29.3× more often in r/Roofing than across the site as a whole.
What people tried
Every workaround mentioned in the threads below. We haven’t tested any of them — and nobody here is claiming they worked.
Found another way around this?
Share your steps and trade-offs so fellow engineers don't have to reinvent the wheel. No account required.
Should I ask the contractor to redo work or take a deduction?
- 1Accepting a price deduction or discount on the final bill instead of making the contractor redo the work.Did this help you?
- 2Catching the crew in the middle of the job and correcting their methods before they finish.Did this help you?
- 3Leaving the incorrect work as-is to avoid risking damage to the surrounding structure during a messy tear-out.Did this help you?
- 4Relying on the final city inspection to catch major issuesDid this help you?
- 5Depending on the equipment warranty if problems emerge laterDid this help you?
- 6Supervising contractors directly while they work to verify steps are takenDid this help you?
- 7Force the contractor to tear off the incorrect material and reinstall the contracted brandDid this help you?
- 8Get a written exemption letter from the manufacturer's local rep stating the warranty remains intact despite the substitutionDid this help you?
- 9Calling the company's service manager to demand a properly equipped lead technician return without an extra trip fee.Did this help you?
- 10Refusing to use large corporate service companies and hiring smaller local shops instead.Did this help you?
- 11Doing the basic physical cleaning and part replacements oneself, relying on professionals only for the specialized testing.Did this help you?
- 12Contacting the local building inspector's office for official backup and verificationDid this help you?
- 13Measuring the length of the conduit and researching electrical code and manufacturer limitationsDid this help you?
- 14Considering paying for an inspection visit out of pocketDid this help you?
In their words
Unedited, grouped by where they were said, most upvoted first within each place, each linked to the thread it came from.
“I don't known if it's possible to easily redo flashing with copper or I should just take the deduction? Can a good roofer redo chimney flashing without doing the entire roof? I'm worried they will mess it more if I ask for a redo.”source ↗
“Might be no difference roof-wise, but warranty-wise the manufacturer now has a get-out-of-jail-free card and the homeowner just paid full price and got a roof with no manufacturer's warranty.”source ↗
“Contractors don't really think about things beyond the job itself. For example, when I was having the roof done on my garage every roofer I spoke to Simply saw the job as removing shingles putting on new shingles. When I started talking about color and type they were like why do you want that color they didn't stop and think that I wanted a certain aesthetic.”source ↗
“Happens every time the perfectly fluent salesperson signs you up, then never relays specifics to the crew actually doing the job. Happened to me when I last had my roof done. Paid for two rolls of ice and water shield that didn't get installed and left the site with the crew, along with six sheets of decking that supposedly needed replaced, that also left in the truck with the crew, Oh, and I had paid extra for 6 nails per shingle, and they were only doing 4.”source ↗
“Until someone fuck you over and ruins your house to save a few bucks because all warranty claims get denied for using the wrong material”source ↗
“I don't understand this attitude from contractors. If it's not a big deal, just communicate that to the client. Don't do something different and leave it to a client to discover and be confused about later.”source ↗
“He did the physical cleaning, nozzle/filter swap, etc., but when it came to checking draft, pump pressure, smoke, or doing a full digital combustion/efficiency test to verify why it had been shaking , having delayed ignition issues and check how clean it was actually burning, he didn't run any of it.”source ↗
“When I asked about the readings, he admitted he didn’t have a combustion analyzer or testing kit on his truck.”source ↗
“Am I being unreasonable for calling the company back to insist they send a lead tech or someone equipped with the right test instruments to verify the setup without charging another diagnostic/trip fee?”source ↗
“Honestly, tune ups are something I've had a problem with since I've started in this field. I've worked for a few different residential hvac companys so far. Tune ups very regularly aren't done right. It's just meant to be a check over, but very regularly things get skipped. Most companies just use it as a easy way to get their techs through the door.”source ↗
“I figured they would really take there time and dial it in properly to get it running to the best of it’s ability as well as make sure it’s safe and that’s worth it but I got the bare minimum it seems.”source ↗
“My contractor installed the heat pumps but the end of the process went very quickly and I suspect he skipped vacuuming and maybe pressure testing, though don’t know for 100% certain.”source ↗
“I am supposed to pay the contractor in full at inspection completion. Is there much I can do?”source ↗
“The contractor is quite pushy and will dodge questions and refuse any “extra work””source ↗
“I panicked because I am sure the ground was broken.”source ↗
“I contacted the solar installer (who sub-contracted the electrical work) and they started to dispute everything with the wildest claims... And they insist it's properly grounded without giving a statement why.”source ↗
“They are willing to schedule a visit but insist I need to pay if it turns out everything is fine. I am disputing this right now but may need to bite the bullet.”source ↗
Where this came up
People with this problem also raised
Related community dilemmas clustered by discussion consensus
Why won't HVAC contractors follow my Manual J report?
Contractors routinely dismiss independent load calculations and insist on using old rules of thumb or installing oversized equipment instead. This leaves homeowners unable to find someone willing to install the correct size system for their home.
How to handle a bad contractor who won't fix poor work
Paying before inspecting leaves homeowners with little leverage when contractors deliver subpar or unauthorized work. Without a clear path to recourse or refunds for shoddy repairs, people are left feeling cheated and stuck with expensive, unsightly results.
What to do when hired contractors stop communicating
Contractors often go silent for days over weekends or fail to respond to texts and voicemails once they have your money, leaving you stranded for hours waiting for answers. This communication blackout leaves you guessing whether to drop them or keep waiting, making it impossible to keep your project moving.
What to do when an installer refuses to fix your system
Installers sometimes abandon a defective unit after multiple failures by claiming they no longer service that specific brand. When this happens, you are left with a broken system and must either demand a full refund or ask the distributor to refer you to a different contractor.
Contractor installed a different size unit without asking
Contractors sometimes swap in a larger unit because they claim the correct size is out of stock, doing so without permission after the sale is finalized. This leaves homeowners stuck with an oversized system and a contractor who stops answering their calls.
Wedding venue wants to change our date after signing contract
When a venue makes a double-booking error and demands a date change despite a signed contract, couples risk losing their non-refundable deposits or facing unexpected financial claims for materials. This breach of agreement destroys trust and leaves couples unsure whether to force compliance or cancel for a full refund without penalty.