Should I replace my failed shingle roof with metal?
Choosing between asphalt shingles and a metal roof is complicated by conflicting advice from contractors and a lack of clear guidance on durability and maintenance trade-offs. This uncertainty leaves property owners struggling to make a confident replacement decision when facing an active roof leak.
Core Friction Pattern
Analysis of 11 peer accounts across online developer and community forums reveals that “Should I replace my failed shingle roof with metal?” repeatedly surfaces due to edge-case mismatches between standard defaults and real-world environments. Standard troubleshooting frequently falls short, compelling practitioners to develop custom workarounds.
+17 alternative community-tested workarounds cataloged below.
What the numbers show
Counted from the threads quoted below. How we count
- Most of it landed at once — the busiest month was September 2026, with 8 people.
- This comes up 31.1× more often in r/Roofing than across the site as a whole.
What people tried
Every workaround mentioned in the threads below. We haven’t tested any of them — and nobody here is claiming they worked.
Found another way around this?
Share your steps and trade-offs so fellow engineers don't have to reinvent the wheel. No account required.
Should I replace my failed shingle roof with metal?
- 1Getting quotes and assessments from multiple roofing companiesDid this help you?
- 2Installing an exposed fastener metal roof over existing shingles using strappingDid this help you?
- 3Doing online researchDid this help you?
- 4Getting multiple opinions from different roofers and inspectorsDid this help you?
- 5Using modified bitumen rolled roofing or permabootsDid this help you?
- 6comparing multiple contractor quotesDid this help you?
- 7researching brand opinions on online forumsDid this help you?
- 8Removing and disposing of the old roofing material completelyDid this help you?
- 9installing snow guards to prevent dangerous snow avalanchesDid this help you?
- 10choosing standing seam metal roofs instead of exposed fastener panelsDid this help you?
- 11selecting low-contrast colors to minimize the visibility of hail dimplesDid this help you?
- 12comparing total cost per expected year rather than just the initial installation priceDid this help you?
- 13Asking on forums for pros and consDid this help you?
- 14Getting quotes for both options to compare costsDid this help you?
- 15getting varied assessments from multiple roofersDid this help you?
- 16researching material durability and warranty differencesDid this help you?
- 17asking community forums for contractor recommendations and opinionsDid this help you?
- 18periodically replacing fasteners or rubber gaskets on an exposed fastener roofDid this help you?
In their words
Unedited, grouped by where they were said, most upvoted first within each place, each linked to the thread it came from.
“My home inspector said I need EPDM rubber or something like it because my pitch is less than 1/12 on our addition. I had a roof inspector come and they said to put the asphalt shingles on and then another roofer offered to also put new shingles on…but don’t I need something for flatter roofs?”source ↗
“I’m on the east coast of Canada (Halifax, Nova Scotia) and need to replace the roof on my rental property. Currently we’ve got an asphalt shingle roof, that has failed and leaked into the attic space.”source ↗
“I don’t know much about roofing and there seems to be a major divide on the exposed fastener roof but I see them a lot where I live. I’d appreciate any advice!”source ↗
“Looking to see which one is the better option for a tar and gravel roof replacement.”source ↗
“My question is which style metal roof to go with - exposed fastener or standing seam?”source ↗
“Are there other benefits to the standing seam than the lack or potentially replacing screws over time that justify the price difference?”source ↗
“one said the roof is ok for a few more years and the other said we need it replaced asap”source ↗
“Hi Roofing, I'll be presenting a list of options to my church's committee this weekend on replacing our roof, and the deeper I look the less certain I am on which are the best offers.”source ↗
“What's the pros and cons I heard metal last forever and expensive but it will pay for itself .”source ↗
“The IB PVC option piqued my interest as I was reading through this sub and seems like a solid roof material but comes at the tradeoff of insulation and I'm trying to gauge if that's worth it or not given the temperate area I live in.”source ↗
“The only downsides so far are the occasional "pinging" noise from expansion in the sun, and heavy rain can be loud even with a LOT of insulation in the roof.”source ↗
“It can be very dangerous if it falls off in large sheets, which is why any metal roof in places that get snow should have snow guards”source ↗
“In front of a garage door it will suddenly slide of and block your car in. Garage door opener triggers it and it a pain to clear when you need to get somewhere.”source ↗
“If you get lots of hail, it's going to dimple your roof. Insurance companies know this and will charge higher premiums”source ↗
Where this came up
People with this problem also raised
Related community dilemmas clustered by discussion consensus
How to choose between roof shingle colors
Choosing a shingle color requires matching specific shades like mission brown or barkwood to your home's unique siding, such as Pacific Blue. Without a clear way to compare them together, homeowners get stuck between conflicting color samples and struggle to visualize the final exterior.
What roofing material works best for a low slope roof?
Low-slope and flat roofs require specific waterproof membranes rather than standard shingles to prevent pooling water and leaks, but conflicting contractor recommendations make it difficult to choose the right option. This leaves homeowners worried about long-term waterproofing, membrane penetrations, and how snow accumulation or ice sliding off upper levels might damage the roof and equipment below.
Where to buy DIY metal roofing materials and matching parts
Finding compatible metal roofing components online is difficult because standard hardware stores carry limited sizes and missing accessories. Homeowners replacing or installing their own roofs struggle to source specific panel dimensions, custom vented closures, and foam insulation thicker than one inch.
Which roofing shingle brand actually lasts and is easy to repair?
Some popular shingle brands like GAF are criticized for being too thin and failing to deliver on their advertised longevity. Additionally, while certain materials may adhere tightly, they can make future roof repairs virtually impossible.
Is a rubber roof worth it for persistent low-pitch leaks?
Persistent leaks around low-pitch features like dormers and fireplaces are often driven by wind-driven rain and ice dams that standard roof repairs fail to stop. Property owners facing recurring damage find themselves stuck in cycles of repeated patch jobs without knowing if a total material change is the right fix.
How to choose the right gutter size and mounting type
Choosing the wrong gutter size can lead to constant clogs from nearby trees like maples, while roof-hung systems risk voiding relatively new roof warranties. Meanwhile, mounting options often get complicated when contractors insist on reinforcing old or weak fascia boards.